The Luck of the Draw
Jul 13, 2008Sometimes it isn't possible to distribute goods evenly. When this happens, we often leave it up to randomness – in the form of lotteries – to decide who gets what. Is this just?
The Luck of the Draw: Live Blogging!
11 July 2008
Today's episode is about Lotteries -- not the state sponsored gambling type, but the type that allocate scarce goods and also burdens. Think of housing lotteries, school admission lotteries, and the draft lotteries. In Ancient Greece many political offices were alloted by lottery. Our question is whether and when lotteries are a just distributive mechanism. Sometimes they seem just the thing. The draft lottery, for example, seemed like a good way of keeping the privileged and connected from gaming the selective service system. But suppose tax rates were assigned by lot, so that your rate of taxation depending no on your ability to pay but on random chance. That seems like an absurdly unjust outcome.
One thing I'd like to ask our guest, Peter Stone, about are whether there are any general principle that explains when and why lotteries are just. It will also be interesting to explore whether lotteries should be used more or less in our social lives. I know that John Perry is an advocate of using a lottery for college admissions. He thinks it would save a lot of time, labor and money and that it would be more fair.
I read a sort of tongue and cheek article that suggested we might be better off choosing senators and representatives by lot. Though the article was written in a somewhat kidding tone, the point it made was worth taking seriously. If office holders were chosen by lottery, that would certainly go a long way toward taking the money out of politics. There would be no need for interminable and expensive campaigns.
There is even an argument in favor of what's called lottery voting. Put all the votes for all candidates or options in a hat. Choose one. Whatever vote is chosen decides the issue or candidate. Such a procedure would give all voices an equal chance of being heard. Isn't that the very essence of democracy?
Obviously, there's a lot to talk and think about. Hopefully, you'll join in during the show. We'll have somebody monitor the comments on this blog entry during the show and if you make a good one, we'll try to include it on air.
Comments (12)
Guest
Wednesday, July 16, 2008 -- 5:00 PM
I listed your broadcast on my blog, but too late fI listed your broadcast on my blog, but too late for the live show :-( Better luck when get back from vacation in mid August.
All the best,
Pastor Jennifer
Guest
Saturday, July 19, 2008 -- 5:00 PM
Hi, I am interested in hearing more about John PerHi, I am interested in hearing more about John Perry's views on using a lottery for college admission. Does he envision all applicants having the same chance of winning, or a system that gives those with higher GPAs a greater chance?
Thanks,
keawe
kophebesti
Sunday, April 19, 2015 -- 5:00 PM
Sounds very interesting.. ISounds very interesting.. I like the way you described the topic with such clarity. This is something I have been thinking about for a long time and you really captured the essence of the subject.
silicone cupcake molds
adminpool
Monday, September 7, 2015 -- 5:00 PM
When the Muslims in UK wantWhen the Muslims in UK want to make preparation to perform hajj, they check the previous record of the tour operators, which are working from last many years and they have executed various tours of Hajj and Umrah successfully and they come up to the expectations of the Muslims. business banking secret
adminpool
Monday, September 7, 2015 -- 5:00 PM
The pilgrims have to giveThe pilgrims have to give their offer of stay in the 4 star hotel or in the 5 star hotel, so their accommodation is arranged according to their plan and they have to pay according to the same plan. business insights today
Guest
Sunday, June 12, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
your blog from where it is toyour blog from where it is to where it could be. Applying the best practices listed here will help you attract and keep readers Pass4sure 100-105, and will help you establish the authority and notoriety in your niche. Getting started is easy and your readers will thank you.
HassanHamayun
Tuesday, August 2, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
Really are a person singleReally are a person single and purchasing possible lifetime partner? The internet is 1 good spot to consider the perfect match to suit your needs. There are usually many internet dating services obtainable. You will discover websites given by people or types of people through worldwide and most singles may access them all. www.datinglook.net
HassanHamayun
Tuesday, August 2, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
The on the web internetThe on the web internet personal ads internet internet dating sites have eliminated in acknowledgement by leaps and variety. With numerous singles seeking to locate a special somebody, online connection sites are usually quickly becoming an ideal way related to meeting likewise singles in the more structured method. www.adultdatingnewyork.net
HassanHamayun
Tuesday, August 2, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
Starting a fresh onlineStarting a fresh online romantic relationship service is much like starting any launch business. It demands careful thought and aspect to consider. Included here will probably be some useful advice which i've learned with time that have helped me to use my internet sites as profitable enterprises www.lifedating.net
HassanHamayun
Tuesday, August 2, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
There's a simple solution toThere's a simple solution to asking a female out on the date that won't place a guy in that type of intimidating situation using the fear associated with rejection through her. Actually, this secret increases the possibility of getting a female out on the date through 100%. www.udating.net
HassanHamayun
Tuesday, August 2, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
Possess a person fulfilledPossess a person fulfilled somebody good and you have to date the actual woman?s? Likely to start relationship? for her may be really stressful should you don?t understand how to proceed. Along with great preparing, you can create to begin dating? which she?ll reminisce really years subsequent. To save you of the actual anxiety as well as stress, here are usually some suggestions in arranging a perfect date for your girl from the dreams. www.datingpro.net
HassanHamayun
Tuesday, August 2, 2016 -- 5:00 PM
With this particularWith this particular technology driven world, nearly each and every facility in addition to service beneath the sun can be acquired at the particular click from the mouse. But one should be sure in the need alone. Babysitter in addition to nanny may appear to be synonymous problems but an in depth look might reveal which there?s an issue in their very own meanings as well as the services they provide .www.techtoolsforactivism.net